...suppose we replace the word "teens" with the word "Hispanics" (or even, say, "Hispanic teens"). Suppose mall management had asked its security people for an assessment of who was causing the most trouble, and the security people replied, "That's easy: It's the Latinos." ...If a mall tried to do that, would the media report the event uncritically ...[o]r would the reporting sound a distinct note of outrage and indignation?Read Steve's entire post: SHAMblog: An unconvincing 'mallrat'-ionale?
A site for skeptics and critical thinkers. Hundreds of real life examples of fallacies, updated regularly. An eBook version of Humbug! The skeptics’ field guide to spotting fallacies in thinking. A weekly podcast on each fallacy: Hunting Humbug 101 – a crash course in shooting down bad arguments. We take fallacies seriously, but not ourselves.
Saturday, July 12, 2008
SHAMblog: An unconvincing 'mallrat'-ionale?
Steve Salerno, author of the book SHAM (on my "to read" list), gives an excellent example of the technique of Substitution. On reading his entire post you'll see he discusses the unquestioned and unconscious bias against teenagers. This particular case was about a ban on teenagers hanging about a shopping mall at particular times. He shows the uncritical bias with a substitution:
Labels:
by Theo,
humbug hunting,
Substitution
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

The Skeptic's Field Guide by Theo Clark and Jef Clark is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
0 comments:
Post a Comment